Classic, cheesy, Italian comfort food is flipped on its head to make this incredible, flavorful, Indian-fusion stuffed jumbo shells recipe – it’s a family favorite dinner idea!
Stuffed Shells!!! Who doesn’t love little boats of jumbo pasta stuffed with savory flavor and swimming in creamy goodness?! These vegetarian Paneer Bhurji Stuffed Shells are perfect – I mean PERFECT – for serving a crowd, and they’re especially great as a meatless main course during the holidays!
I created this baked stuffed pasta recipe with paneer, mozzarella, & parmesan, loads of seasonings, and veggies (like spinach, onion, green chilis and mushrooms) but you could most certainly make a meaty version with your favorite protein. Serve this savory, saucy recipe with garlic bread on the side! Make life easy and pop some good ol’ buttery Texas Toast into the oven or make my Green Garlic Bread with scallions, cilantro and jalapeno goodness – YUM!
As always, if you enjoy this recipe I’d love for you to leave a comment on this blog post or tag me in your Instagram stories @thechutneylife ! Happy Eating!



More Mouthwatering Meatless Main Courses!
- Veggie Tikka Masala Stuffed Shells
- Chimichangas with Queso
- Spicy Mac & Cheese
- Creamy Poblano Enchiladas
Few Important Tips
- I use Swad brand paneer but there are a ton of options!
- You can use whatever veggies you have on hand! Feel free to replace the mushrooms or spinach with other veggies like eggplant, kale etc.
- I use Barilla Jumbo Shells. Make sure you do not overcook the shells since they will cook again in the oven. Boil until they are about 80% cooked – if they are too soft they will fall apart on you!
- This recipe makes about 25-30 shells. As a side dish, 3 shells per person is a decent serving. As a main course, account for 4-6 shells per person.
- Leftover paneer can be used on flatbread or pizza crust to make Paneer Pizzas or place it in a paratha with chutney for a quick wrap!
Can I Make Baked Stuffed Shells Ahead of Time?
These Paneer Stuffed Shells are easy to make in advance! Try these tips:
- Make the paneer stuffing 1-2 days ahead of time and keep it refrigerated
- If you don’t want to make the paneer completely ahead of time, you can prep the garlic, chop the peppers, crumble the paneer ahead of time.
- Use this amazing Vegetable Chopper from Amazon to making chopping SO much easier!
- You can even cook and pre-stuff the shells eariler on the day you’re serving this recipe, just make sure to keep them covered so they do not dry out. Wait to pour the sauce on the shells right before baking to prevent them from getting soggy.
What Filling Goes in Stuffed Shells?
Jumbo pasta shells are the perfect bowl for lots of different fillings! In this Indian-inspired recipe, I’m using Paneer, spinach, onion and mushrooms for a rich, comforting dish! But shells can also be filled with a classic Bolognese meat sauce, a chicken Alfredo sauce, seafood, sausage, ground turkey, or a combo of ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan with egg (to bind the cheese together.) Find your favorite!


my husband loves this RECIPE the only thing i can add is the INGREDIENTs don’t say onion and green pepper until I get to the directions so i always forget it at the grocery store when grabbing things for this.
ahh I will fix it thank you!